Commentary: Why the American example still matters in this age of 'America First'

Perhaps one of the more fascinating things to emerge from the interview with Dan Coats that appears in the November edition of The Ripon Forum is who Coats says is the American most responsible for helping to bring down communism in 1991. The Forum reached out to the veteran Indiana policymaker to get his thoughts on the fall of the Berlin Wall 30 years ago, and the state of world affairs today. Coats is in a better position than most to discuss these topics.

When the Wall came down in 1989, he was serving in the Senate as a member of the Armed Services Committee. Just over a decade later, he was appointed U.S. ambassador to Germany. He arrived in Berlin just before the 9/11 terrorist attacks and helped guide relations between our two countries in the tenuous weeks and months that followed. Most recently, of course, Coats served as director of national intelligence in the Trump administration.

All of this is to say that Coats has seen a lot and done a lot over the course of his distinguished career. Which is why it was so interesting when he named John Davis as the fourth person — after Lech Wałęsa, Mikhail Gorbachev and Pope John Paul II — who had “the most critical role in bringing about the collapse of communism in Eastern Europe.”

I have to admit I’d never heard of Davis, so I Googled him. As it turns out, he served as chief of mission at the U.S. Embassy in Warsaw from 1983 to 1988, and U.S. ambassador to Poland from 1988 to 1990. At a time when some members of the U.S. Foreign Service are being accused of being members of the “deep state,” it is notable that a respected Republican like Dan Coats would point to a career diplomat like John Davis as being even more responsible than Ronald Reagan for bringing down the Berlin Wall.

An article that appeared in the Dec. 21, 1989, edition of The New York Times helps explain why Coats feels this way. Published less than six weeks after the Wall came down, it is an account of how Davis gained influence in Warsaw over the years — first by hosting separate dinners with members of the Communist government and the Solidarity Labor Union, and then by hosting dinners where both members of the government and labor leaders were invited. “Communists mingled with Solidarity people,” the Times reported. “Former prisoners clinked glasses with their jailers. The result is that Ambassador John R. Davis Jr. now commands attention and respect in Poland. It is no small success.”

No small success. If there were ever an understatement written about that period, it would be that one. And yet “understated” is perhaps the best word that can be used to describe America’s quiet diplomacy during that pivotal time. It was the type of diplomacy not only practiced by Ambassador Davis but exemplified by President George H.W. Bush. In an essay in this same edition of the Forum, historian Jeffrey Engel writes how America’s 41st president approached this period of upheaval. “He did not shout, he did not gloat, he did not boast,” Engel writes. “Bush instead mostly listened during those tumultuous weeks and months of promise and anxiety in 1989, knowing that every time he listened more than he talked when a foreign leader called, and every time he kept his word, faith in him grew.”

Of course, faith in America grew, too — faith in America as a force for good, and faith in America as a symbol of peace, justice and freedom.

Dan Coats touches on this sentiment in his interview when he talks about the hundreds of Germans who showed up outside the gates of the U.S. Embassy in Berlin to pay their respects on 9/11. “I recall with considerable emotion talking with a German woman of my generation as she laid her flowers on the mountain of bouquets at the embassy’s entrance,” Coats said. “She said that Americans had helped Germany at its time of greatest need in the trying times after World War II. She talked about the Berlin Airlift, the Marshall Plan and the firm defense against Soviet aggression. This woman represented the immediate post-war generation marked by deep gratitude toward the United States for our contributions to Germany’s peace and prosperity. This generation continues to love America.”

It has been 18 years since the terrorist attacks, and three decades since the fall of the Berlin Wall. A lot has clearly changed during that time. What has not changed is the important role that America plays in the world, and the importance of America continuing to be a global force for good. This role is especially critical not only at a time when populism is on the rise and democracies are under assault, but when many are arguing that U.S. policymakers should focus less on promoting the American example and more on promoting America first.

Coats rejected this argument. “I believe this is something of a false dichotomy,” he told the Forum. “Our core national interests — peace, prosperity, security — have always included nurturing everywhere our core values. Extending benefits of freedom, democracy, human rights and free enterprise to others has always served our national interests. This is the real ‘America First.’”

It is also the America that career diplomat John Davis promoted as U.S. ambassador to Poland, when he helped defeat communism and bring the Cold War to an end.

Lou Zickar is the editor of The Ripon Forum, a centrist Republican journal of political thought published by the Ripon Society.

Get a weekly recap of South Carolina opinion and analysis from The Post and Courier in your inbox on Monday evenings.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News

Free Times Breaking News