As recently as a decade ago, the word “heirloom” was used to describe jewels, furniture or handicrafts — one-of-a-kind items of uncommon quality or design — that were passed down by families over generations. Now, that tag is just as frequently attached to vegetables, fruit and flowers.
Enthusiasts say heirloom vegetables offer more flavor, nostalgia and authenticity.
“I think it’s all about the flavor,” said Kathy Mendelson, a botanist from the Seattle area and author of a website called “The Heirloom Vegetable Gardener’s Assistant.”
“Nobody wants a plateful of bland for dinner, and the best of the heirlooms have flavors that are complicated: delicate, bold, sweet, not sweet, rich, distinctive and more,” Mendelson said.
Nostalgia plays an important part, too, she said, but heirlooms are more than just sentimental favorites: “For example, they can have to do with family, community, certainly with culture, and also History with a capital ‘H’ — researched and documented.”
What’s not to love when growing tomatoes from seeds given such descriptive names as “Radiator Charlie’s Mortgage Lifter,” “Brandywine,” “Trucker’s Favorite” or “Amish Paste”?
Tomatoes are the favorite heirlooms, but have been eclipsed in the marketplace by hybrid varieties created for disease resistance, appearance and longer shelf life.
“Breeding has changed,” said Diane Ott Whealy, co-founder of Seed Savers Exchange in Decorah, Iowa, the largest nongovernment seed bank in the United States.
“Commercial growers wanted vegetables like tomatoes to ripen off the vine, survive being shipped cross-country and then mature in warehouses before going into stores,” she said, but added that they misplaced something in the process: flavor.
“People come to us and say they remember the juicy tomato from their grandmother’s garden. Tomatoes in markets today just don’t have that,” Ott Whealy said.
Along with scores of heirloom tomato varieties, old-school squash, potatoes, beans, peppers, cucumbers, carrots, herbs and melons also are popular with modern-day gardeners. And let’s not forget heirloom flowers.
“Genetics over time has made them stronger, more diverse,” Ott Whealy said. “Heirloom flowers have more pollen and more nectar for butterflies.”
Heirloom vegetables are proven survivors, said Sarah Browning, an extension horticulturist with the University of Nebraska-Lincoln.
“Heirloom plants were created by gardeners who repeatedly saved seed from the healthiest, most productive and flavorful plants from their garden,” Browning said. “So inadvertently, these gardeners also selected for disease resistance.”