You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
top story

How a fake Charleston baseball team and its fan art are taking over the internet

  • Updated

Everyone's heard of baseball, America's favorite pastime, but an online fantasy league called blaseball is taking over the internet during a year in which fans were barred from sharing a bag of peanuts and cheering on their team at the stadium. 

Blaseball is not just your typical fantasy league, but a bizarre imaginary gaming sphere in which pitchers' stats improve for having 11 fingers and a giant peanut god can strike down base runners at a whim. 

It's an imaginative realm, created in the midst of a pandemic that upended the sporting and events world, which draws in baseball fans and Dungeons and Dragons players alike. The result is an enterprising, and a bit nerdy, tight-knit community.

Get a weekly list of tips on pop-ups, last minute tickets and little-known experiences hand-selected by our newsroom in your inbox each Thursday.

blaseball rollin 1.jpg

Esme Ramsey, a player for the Charleston Shoe Thieves, had the misfortune of becoming a spirit medium, leading to a succession of previously-incinerated baseball players manifesting her body. RollinKunz!/Provided


“It’s really like ‘geek church’ or a comic convention," offers one fan artist who goes by RollinKunz!

One team on the roster shares a name with the Holy City: The Charleston Shoe Thieves. That's because the game's animator, Cedric Adams, was born in Charleston and loves buying shoes. 

The thing is, though, the Shoe Thieves' thousands of fans, who "watch" hourly online games unfold (really, the computer randomly generates game play and it's then discussed on the fan instant messaging platform Discord) are from all over the world, not just here in the Lowcountry. 

"Blaseball players are all unique, be they ghosts, animals, robots or people of every shape, size and color. In the same vein, I’ve met fans from all over, from South Korea to British Columbia," offers Jonathan Glenn, a 23-year-old Charleston Shoe Thieves fan from Knoxville, Tenn., who has created accompanying art around some of his favorite players, like the team's former pitcher Beasley Gloom, whom he depicts as a bulldog. 

It's the camaraderie between folks of all different backgrounds that truly makes blaseball such a unique and accepting community. 

"I normally absolutely cannot stand sports," offers one fan artist who goes by Horse Hoffman. "But blaseball is just as accessible to any staunchly anti-league-sports person as it is to any longtime fan of the major leagues."

blaseball horse 2.jpg

The piece by Horse Hoffman is of Charleston Shoe Thieves player Tillman Henderson. Horse Hoffman/Provided

Blaseball's creators — Stephen Bell, Joel Clark and Sam Rosenthal of video game studio The Game Band in Los Angeles — made the game in July and didn't expect the farcical simulation to spur quite the giant fan base it has, currently ringing in at more than 30,000 folks on Discord. 

"At the time, I remember being in the mental state of, 'I can't believe I'm working on this silly idea professionally. Let me just have fun with this and just let the ideas pour out,’” said Clark. 

That's how player statistics got to be determined by things like "Shakespearianism," "chasiness" and "unthwackability." 

There are rules, but the rules are not tied to reality, and the imaginative minds of the creators let absurdities reign.

Fans have a chance to have their say in what unfolds on the field outside of typical game play, as well. For instance, an inning might be interrupted by targeted incinerations of players, who end up in the "Hall of Flame." 

It's a mismatch of sports, comedy and horror, all rolled into one.

It's "Welcome to Nightvale" meets "Angels in the Outfield" and "The Sandlot," offers Taquin Jackson, a local behind the Charleston Shoe Thieves Twitter fan account. 

But that's what attracts so many creatives, from fan fiction writers to Twitter account creators to one 26-year-old from the United Kingdom who started a whole Blaseball record label called Fourth Strike. Its songs have racked up more than half-a-million streams across Spotify and Bandcamp. 

blaseball kyle 3.jpg

Charleston Shoe Thieves character Blood Hamburger, depicted by blaseball fan Kyle Armstrong. Kyle Armstrong/Provided

"We definitely hoped that people would like the game, and we've tried to create a space for the fans to inject themselves into the experience, but we could never have foreseen the degree to which they've run with it," said Bell. 

Among blaseball teams are the Kansas City Breath Mints, San Francisco Lovers and Canada Moist Talkers. But the Charleston Shoe Thieves have captured the hearts of those with a flare for the dramatic who like to root for the underdog.

It's really the creative characters on the team who have drawn fans in. 

"I chose the Shoe Thieves because I loved the name. I stuck around for the players and their descriptions that inspired me to draw," offered fan artist Kyle Armstrong from Austin, Tex.

Among those descriptors were "a 13-foot-tall Halloween skeleton," "the biggest woman in blaseball" and "an enamel monster." He ran with those ideas and created "blaseball cards" depicting his favorites.

Kiersten Hoff, an 18-year-old college student from Northern Illinois, selected the Charleston Shoe Thieves because of the story lore. There's Jaylen Hotdogfingers' death and resurrection, the "Grand Unslam" and the peanut fraud fiasco of Season 3. 

blaseball kiersten 2.jpg

Gunther O'Brian, as depicted by Kiersten Hoff. Kiersten Hoff/Provided

Hoff was drawn to a team favorite, Gunther O'Brian, for her illustrations. 

“It’s almost universally agreed upon that Gunter is a penguin, but if you wanna say he’s a man with a lizard head, then he’s a man with a lizard head," Hoff said. 

Imagination runs wild not only in the game but accompanying fan art. It only makes sense, since the site’s graphics are barren. It’s up to artists to help fill in the fiction for others. That's part of the fun. 

And while "Charleston" might apply to many different cities around the globe, a concept debated among blaseball followers, the Shoe Thieves' stadium is located in "Mount Pleasant" according to fan lore.

That sounds local to me — well, as local as you can get other than the Charleston RiverDogs, of course. 

Reach Kalyn Oyer at 843-371-4469. Follow her on Twitter @sound_wavves.

Kalyn Oyer is a Charleston native who covers arts & entertainment and food & bev for The Post and Courier. She's a music festival & concert photographer and used to write about music for the Charleston City Paper, among other publications.