Progress made, but 'this fire is not done'

By Tony Bartelme , Warren Wise
The Post and Courier
Saturday, April 25, 2009



photo

The Post and Courier

Gov. Mark Sanford views the damage at Sherry Martin's home with her son Chris Whaley of the St. Johns Fire District.

Video

Friday Wildfire Press Conference

photo

The Post and Courier

Full coverage

For photo galleries, videos and more fire coverage, go to postandcourier.com/multimedia

NORTH MYRTLE BEACH — A ferocious wildfire that has scorched nearly 20,000 acres and caused at least $16 million in damage here began in the backyard of a home eight miles inland — and a world away from the resort homes hit hardest by the flames.

The yard belongs to Mark Torchi and Megan Brogan, and Friday afternoon, with the woods still smoldering around her home, Brogan told The Post and Courier that people shouldn't blame them for what happened.

The roots of this week's wildfire — the worst South Carolina has seen in three decades, destroying 69 homes — actually began last Saturday, she and fire officials said. Brogan said her husband built a trash fire behind their home that day.

"Yes, the only thing we did wrong was that we didn't get a burn permit, but that happens all the time in the country." When the fire accidentally got into the woods, she said she immediately called 911. "We called 911 and they were supposed to put out the fire. That's what we pay our taxes for."

Firefighters with Horry County Fire and Rescue responded quickly, but she felt they could have done more to prevent the fire from reigniting. "I totally blame the Horry County Fire Department because they could have soaked up the whole woods around here," she said, pointing to a hydrant in front of her home. "But they never used that hydrant."

Horry County firefighters who responded last Saturday to Woodlawn Drive thought they had put out the fire until it flared up with high winds and dry conditions Wednesday.

"Nothing was happening that anybody noticed. We responded on Wednesday with the firefighters when we learned it was spreading," said Russell Hubright of the state Forestry Commission, who is based in Columbia. "In fairness to these guys (Horry County firefighters), they put out hundreds of these fires every year. Why this one rekindled is a little bit of a mystery."

On Wednesday, high winds hit the area, and the fire behind her house quickly spread to the woods and the rest of her neighborhood, a mix of mobile homes and modest vinyl-sided houses.

Fire spreads

From her backyard, the fire traveled more than 10 miles in two days, consuming 31 square miles of forest and subdivisions, an area roughly three times the size of the Charleston peninsula. The fire traveled as far east as Barefoot Resort and Grande Dunes golf club, which at one point used sprinklers to prevent the links from going up in smoke, officials said.

Paul Whitman, Horry County's Director of Public Safety, said low winds and a temperature inversion early Friday morning helped keep the fire tamped down, though at times visibility from the heavy smoke made it impossible to see your hand in front of your face. Despite the scale and intensity of the fire, no serious injuries or fatalities had been reported.

Whitman said emergency crews used NASA satellite images to pinpoint hotspots and help them decide where to dispatch crews and helicopters. More than 450 firefighters from 33 agencies across South Carolina and North Carolina, including crews from North Charleston, Charleston, Isle of Palms and Summerville, were on the scene Friday. More than 30 volunteers helped evacuate several dozen horses and other animals.

Whitman said he was worried that coastal winds and higher temperatures would push the fire from the Lewis Bay Ocean Heritage Preserve, an unpopulated area on the outskirts of North Myrtle Beach, to the Poplar and Wampee communities, where several thousand people live. "This fire is not done," he said. "We have several days to go."

But Friday afternoon, as ash drifted into North Carolina, officials were becoming more optimistic about getting the fire under control.

'Tornado and a fire'

Officials said late Friday that firefighters had the wildfire had been 80 percent contained after ridding the area of underbrush that serves as fuel.

Breezes were keeping the fire inland, still away from the main tourist areas.

Crews continued to plow firebreaks into critical areas and burn underbrush and trees ahead of the blaze to rob its fuel. They hoped the winds would stay calm into this morning, said state Forestry Commission spokeswoman Holly Welch.

Still, winds were expected to increase after sunrise and the fire remained dangerous.

"If just one ember gets out in front of a firebreak, this thingcould flare back up quickly," Welch said.

Pete Rogers of Awendaw, a public information officer for the Lowcountry Incident Management Team, said his crew was told it could go back home to Charleston. "If you are going home, that means there's a light at the end of the tunnel."

Gov. Mark Sanford flew over fire area Friday and then visited the North Myrtle Beach neighborhood where dozens of homes were destroyed. Later, at a press briefing in Conway, he said half of the wildfire was under control, but that "the storm is not over." He said the blaze had caused $16 million in damage and that he expected that number to rise.

"It was like a tornado and a fire," he said of the damage in Barefoot Resort, a subdivision along the Intracoastal Waterway that was hit hard. "This is cataclysmic damage to individual homes but not on a scale of a hurricane."

Sanford added that people should focus now on fighting the fire instead of finding someone to blame. He says once the flames are out, he will ask for a review of everything that happened.

Did what they could

The neighborhood where the fire began is off S.C. Highway 90, a country road that leads out of Conway toward the swamps of the Waccamaw River.

Friday afternoon, white smoke still drifted from nearby stumps as Brogan, 29, said she was furious that people are blaming her family for the disaster.

When the trash fire got out of control last Saturday in her backyard, she immediately called 911. "What else are we supposed to do?"

Torchi, 39, said late Friday he fears for his family because people are upset about the damage. Brogan said the family has received death threats.

Several neighbors said that it was wrong to blame Torchi and Brogan for the fire.

Al Whittaker said firefighters spent several hours putting out the fire last Saturday after Torchi's yard debris fire started to spread into the brush by his home.

"They didn't come in with a bulldozer or anything," Whittaker said. "Sunday, Monday and Tuesday goes by. How come nobody comes by and checks? ... How is this thing coming back on him five days later? It's one of the more twisted, insensible things I've heard."

Forestry Commission Forest Protection Chief Darryl Jones said it's common for brush fires to appear to be out but then smolder underground and rekindle. But he said blame belongs to the person who set it. "The Fire Department didn't start the fire," Jones said. "Someone lit it and somebody let it escape and that's where this all started."

The Forestry Commission ticketed Torchi for last Saturday's fire, not the one that reignited Wednesday. He was cited for failing to notify the commission of an outdoor burn, which carries a fine up to $262.50, as well as for allowing the fire to spread, which carries a fine up to $470. Hubright said no additional tickets will be issued.

Brogan said when the fire reignited Wednesday, it built quickly. She said Horry County firefighters watched as the flames headed toward nearby homes. "The only reason my house didn't burn down is that my neighbors and I got a garden hose and put water on the house."

Horry County Fire and Rescue Chief Gary Alderman said firefighters often let woods fires burn close to the house and let the flames consume fuel before they attack it in force. Sometimes the flames are so powerful, however, that firefighters have to practice a form of triage, letting some houses go that can't be saved. "It's often a split-second decision," he said. "For every house that was destroyed, we saved six others."

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

FOLLOW THIS STORY

Go to postandcourier.com/mbfires to follow twitter feeds about the fire.

Share this story:
E-mail this story E-mail this story  Printer-friendly version Printer-friendly version  

Copy and paste the link:

Add this

Comments

DougHuffman (anonymous) says...

"...they were supposed to put out the fire. That's what we pay our taxes for."

Read Atlas Shrugged by Ayn Rand. No, you pay your taxes so that 'they' can mooch a living. Remember, moochers and looters? YOU are solely responsible for the results of your actions, the effects that you cause.

Either we are equal or we are not. Good people ought to be armed where they will, with wits and guns and the truth.

April 25, 2009 at 7:33 a.m. ( | suggest removal )

MedicChas2 (anonymous) says...

When someone starts a brush fire, the fire department responds and does their best to extinguish it. A rekindle is something that happens, typically within a few hours or the next day. This case, where it rekindles in a few days is rare. The Horry County Fire-Rescue Department did not decide to burn their garbage without following permit policies, so to blame them is not fair.

I have worked brush fire before. It is very hard to fight these fires, and the Horry County firefighters and the mutual aid companies are doing an excellent job in this situation.

April 25, 2009 at 8:33 a.m. ( | suggest removal )

Rebel_Yell (anonymous) says...

I blame the Brogan lady. Our taxes are not for putting out fires intentially set by people who are too lazy to take their trash to the dump or curb. She needs to fix her attitude as well seeing that she will be the defendant in hundreds of lawsuits-and rightfully so. Go ahead and take your shirt off your back Ms brogan because you will have to give that up too when this is all said and done. If you know what your doing, an outside burn is a controlled fire. If it escapes, it's your responsibility and it's certainly foreseeable that an uncontrolled fire could rekindle.

"The only thing we did wrong was not getting a permit" said Brogan. Not so -- how 'bout not having the capacity to control the fire which allowed it to escape in the first place. Typical food stamp response for her to say her taxes are paid so others can put out her messes. 1000 judgments should get her attention so maybe she will not risk the lives and property of others again.

April 25, 2009 at 9:25 a.m. ( | suggest removal )

emerson15 (anonymous) says...

For shame! Blame the fire department? In my opion the burning of trash and garbage should be illegal, period! But that's beside the point. Of coarse these people are ultimately responsible for what happened and should suffer the legal consequenses.

April 25, 2009 at 10:33 a.m. ( | suggest removal )

damnyank63 (anonymous) says...

It's pretty sad when the person who starts the fire can't own up to his or her responsibility. I don't think the families who have lost everything will buy the argument that it was the FD's fault. Just an unbelievably ignorant comment.

April 25, 2009 at 11:52 a.m. ( | suggest removal )

tc2 (anonymous) says...

Typical today, "not my fault".

April 25, 2009 at 12:13 p.m. ( | suggest removal )

1963 (anonymous) says...

I bet the next time they want to burn trash that they will get a permit.

April 25, 2009 at 12:20 p.m. ( | suggest removal )

TLG87 (anonymous) says...

Hmm, seeing as it was Brogan & her husband who started the fire, let it escape to the woods, and not get a burn permit, I can just totally see how its the fire departments fault (/sarcasm).

They need to own up to their actions. I cant even understand how the woman thinks that's a valid excuse. She had quite a few stupid comments quoted in the story.

April 25, 2009 at 12:41 p.m. ( | suggest removal )

gentlebear (anonymous) says...

Here is the thing ms brogan no one should cause you harm. see the thing here is that you are typical of your generation. You lack accountablity and sensitivity. I might add you are lazy. And you lack morality. Where do I start so that you maybe come a better person. Oh I know people are going to say that I'm judging you but I'm not. In fact I beleive not one person came to you in truthful love or if thaey did you rejected it. Okay lets start with what you may say is the most judgemental part. Why is a single unmarried woman lving with a single man? Please do not give me any of the cheap excuses. Lazy why where you burning items take them to the recycle center. Yea it amy take longer but even if the fire did not happen the air would have been cleaner for your neighbors. Oh yea you are selfish.You did not have a permit you should be fined as what the law allows nothing more. If you got the permit they would have expalin a few things to you. Then you say everyone is doing boy I could state many things here but will not all get the picture. The sadest part, you are worried about saving your face. You do not even sound as if you have a little bit of sorrow.
ms brogan I'll be praying for you, Not that any harm from people should come to you but rather you become broken.
I have no hard or ill feelings towards you and by the way I live in the area of the fire and a victim. Please understand that I'm not judging you or upset with you, rather just pointing out this the time you need to be others focused, not save face focus. Oh by the way if I'm wrong I'm sorry, but why would you answer the papers stating it's not my fault. Why not say I wish this never happened. I would have said, Today is a sad day let's focus on the real issues, those that are in need and you may also be one. Wish you blessings

April 25, 2009 at 1:04 p.m. ( | suggest removal )

fyrefighter273 (anonymous) says...

In another post concerning a related story it was clear it was the fire departments fault. I see some thoughts are changing as time wears on. It is against the law to burn garbage, lots of folks do it. I have a friend living in Summerville in town and his neighbor burns in a trash can regular. She sees no problem but we know better.I have another friend that lives in the Outer Banks of NC and would not even dare trying that, he said he could not recall ever getting toned out for a trash fire. 4 days and some change seems like a long time for a small trash fire to smolder then reignite, not saying it could not have happened. Like to see what happens when the lawyers get involved in this one.

April 25, 2009 at 1:07 p.m. ( | suggest removal )

jigirl (anonymous) says...

Whatever happened to apologizing and saying you regret what happened? I was amazed this woman could blame people for her actions. I don't know about most readers, but its been to darn windy to even fly a kite lately, much less try to do a "controlled" burn. Who burns trash nowadays anyways. Uh, oh - I'm leaving the door wide open there aren't I?

April 25, 2009 at 2:45 p.m. ( | suggest removal )

satscout (anonymous) says...

I agree, the trash burn should never have been done. But why didn't the fire department soak the area afterward? She said they never even used the hydrant in front of her house... Primary blame, if any is to be issued, is to the people who did the trash burn in the first place, but it seems to me that if you KNOW a fire has been there, it only makes sense to soak the place afterward to prevent reignition, especially if there is a hydrant close by.

April 25, 2009 at 5:14 p.m. ( | suggest removal )

lowcountrymouth (anonymous) says...

As I said before, these people give trailer trash a bad name. . .

April 25, 2009 at 6:06 p.m. ( | suggest removal )

dawnies5 (anonymous) says...

I find it hard to believe that people are completely blaming these people for this fire. They CALLED the fire department, they responded and the fire was not put out completely. HOW IS THIS THEIR FAULT?? Granted they should have not have let the fire get out of control but they did what anyone else would have done, called the fire department. Now had they just let it burn and not contacted anyone then you could blame them.

April 25, 2009 at 7:14 p.m. ( | suggest removal )

Notice about comments:

Postandcourier.com is pleased to offer readers the enhanced ability to comment on stories. We expect our readers to engage in lively, yet civil discourse. Postandcourier.com does not edit user submitted statements and we cannot promise that readers will not occasionally find offensive or inaccurate comments posted in the comments area. Responsibility for the statements posted lies with the person submitting the comment, not postandcourier.com. If you find a comment that is objectionable, please click "report abuse" and we will review it for possible removal. Please be reminded, however, that in accordance with our Terms of Use and federal law, we are under no obligation to remove any third party comments posted on our website. Read our full Terms and Conditions.

Users can now build user-to-user connections, follow friends' recent posts, add an avatar that fits their personality, and more. If you have posted here before you'll need to sign up again, or if you've never posted before, start now by signing up!


 

Most Popular

 

Sponsored Links