JERUSALEM - Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu last week criticized the U.N.'s cultural agency for postponing an exhibit on Jewish connections to the Holy Land following objections from Arab countries.
The spat centers around one of the thorniest issues at the heart of Israeli-Palestinian peace talks: Israel's demand for recognition as a Jewish state. Israel says there cannot be Mideast peace without Palestinian acceptance of Israel as the Jewish homeland. The Palestinians say such recognition would undercut the rights of Palestinian refugees and Israel's own Arab minority.
The exhibition, which is called "People, Book, Land: The 3,500-Year Relationship of the Jewish People to the Holy Land," had been scheduled to open Jan. 20 at UNESCO's headquarters in Paris.
But before the opening, UNESCO abruptly announced it was delaying the exhibit after 22 Arab member states said in a letter that it could disrupt Israeli-Palestinian peace negotiations. The U.N. agency also said it needed extra time to revise "unresolved issues relating to potentially contestable textual and visual historical points" that member states could perceive as "endangering the peace process."
Rabbi Marvin Hier of the Simon Wiesenthal Center, a U.S. Jewish group that co-organized the exhibit, said UNESCO had already approved the exhibit and even begun setting it up at UNESCO's Paris headquarters.
"This is absolutely preposterous," said Heir. "The educational and cultural headquarters of the United Nations (is saying) to the world, 'Every people's history is welcome to be told in these corridors, except for one people, the Jewish people.' "
The exhibit was to show roughly 30 illustrated panels showing the long history of the Jewish people in the Holy Land, from the days of the biblical patriarch Abraham to modern day Israel as a high-tech powerhouse.
"One of the things that this exhibition very clearly shows is that the Jewish presence in the holy land has been continuous," said the creator of the exhibit, Hebrew University professor Robert Wistrich.
"This is the accurate true story and it goes against the fashionable but highly misleading perception that the Jewish presence is the result of some kind of late-19th-century colonial project or is the consequence of the Holocaust."
Wistrich said every line of the text had been "scrutinized and vetted and examined and re-examined" by UNESCO experts. He called it "absolutely mindboggling" that the entire exhibit had been called off by what he said was "an entirely predictable" objection by Arab countries.
Speaking to his Cabinet, Netanyahu rejected the claim that the exhibit would harm peace negotiations. "It would not harm the negotiations. Negotiations are based on facts, on the truth, which is never harmful," he said.
Many Palestinian officials deny or dispute Jewish historical ties to Israel.
The Palestinians say that such recognition would harm claims by hundreds of thousands of Palestinian refugees and their descendants who wish to return to lost properties in what is now Israel.
The American ambassador to the U.N., Samantha Power, has called on UNESCO to open the exhibit. "UNESCO is supposed to be fostering discussion and interaction between civil society and member states, and organizations such as the Wiesenthal Center have a right to be heard and to contribute to UNESCO's mission."
Notice about comments:
The Post and Courier is pleased to offer readers the enhanced ability to comment on stories. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point.