North Carolina regulators clear hurdle to Duke-Progress merger
RALEIGH — North Carolina utilities regulators on Friday approved the long-planned takeover of Progress Energy by Duke Energy, clearing the last major hurdle to creating the largest American electric company.
The combined company will serve about 3 million customers in North Carolina and 4 million more in South Carolina, Kentucky, Ohio, Indiana and Florida.
South Carolina regulators still must approve the merged company’s plan for operating its combined electrical generation system, but they are not weighing in on the merger. They have scheduled a meeting Monday.
The deal initially valued at $13.7 billion will give it the most customers, power capacity and market value in the U.S.
“This is a blockbuster. It creates a very large entity that should be pretty stable,” said Steve Piper, an energy consultant at SNL Energy.
The company led by Charlotte-based Duke Energy will be able to borrow money more cheaply as it sheds more coal-burning power plants, builds facilities able to burn cheaper natural gas, and considers more investment in nuclear energy, Piper said. If the Southeast is able to return to heady economic growth rates that preceded the recession, the combined company can maintain stable and even declining power rates, he said.
Raleigh-based Progress also operates in heavily regulated states and has been more protected from the recent decrease in wholesale power prices than Duke, which operates in deregulated states like Ohio.
Regulators saw the deal as the best possible in an environment of energy industry consolidation, North Carolina Utilities Commission chairman Edward Finley Jr. said.
“It seems far preferable for Progress Energy to merge with North Carolina-headquartered Duke Energy than with a company in another state,” he said.
Conditions North Carolina regulators placed on the deal include the combined company passing along at least $650 million in savings to state customers. The merger also is expected to result in operating efficiencies that will mean lower future rate increases, the commission said.
Any costs related to completing the merger can’t be passed on to North Carolina utility customers, the commission said. That includes severance costs of about $230 million as Duke and Progress shed up to 1,900 jobs.
The combined company will depend on borrowing for its plant updates. The need for lower borrowing costs was also behind Exelon Corp.’s $7.9 billion takeover of Constellation Energy Group earlier this year, said Phil Adams, a senior bond analyst at Gimme Credit LLC, which provides the financial industry with independent research into corporate bond borrowing.
“We have a very fragmented utilities industry in this country and when you’re making multi-billion-dollar capital decisions for assets that are expected to be used for the next 35 to 40 years, bigger is better. It helps your access to capital markets,” Adams said.
There are significant challenges facing the combined company, Adams said. They include coping with the costs of a shutdown at Progress Energy’s Crystal River nuclear plant in Florida, $1.3 billion in cost overruns at a Duke coal-gasification plant in Indiana, and Ohio’s deregulated market, Adams said.
The merger announced in January 2011 has been approved by a series of state and federal agencies, the most significant coming earlier this month when the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission gave its blessing. The FERC twice rejected the merger because of concerns it would reduce competition for wholesale electricity in the Carolinas.
Duke Energy says it plans a reverse stock split once it completes its Progress purchase, giving shareholders one share in the expanded company for every three shares they now own. The stock price for each share will triple, so that the overall value of the shares remains the same.
Shares of Duke Energy Corp. rose 2 cents to $23.08 Friday. Progress Energy Inc. stock fell 1 cent to $60.17.